The creator of “Only Murders in the Building” discusses casting Meryl Streep
Only Murders in the Building, created by John Hoffman and Steve Martin, received 21 Emmy nominations this year, including one for best comedy series — a milestone that Hoffman, a four-time Emmy winner, considers “affirming,” according to The Hollywood Reporter.
***
How did the story at the center of season three come together?
For me to have confidence in leading a writers room and developing a season for a show like this with such a talented cast, I needed to deeply understand the story. I based Oliver (Martin Short’s character) on my late theater professor, Dr. Richard Mason, known as “The Mayor of Charles Street” in Greenwich Village. The creative journey of Oliver, especially turning a straight play into a musical, required a bold approach. The intricate romance with the new leading lady was also part of the story before we even cast the role.
How did you end up casting Meryl Streep for the role?
It was a surreal experience. While discussing the opening scene for season three with EPs Dan Fogelman and Jess Rosenthal, I mentioned that Meryl Streep would be perfect for a role. Two weeks later, I received a text from Steve and Martin about Meryl expressing interest in working together. After a call with Meryl, she agreed to join the show, leaving me in disbelief.
How did your first discussion with her go?
During a nervous Zoom pitch, I described the character to Meryl. To my surprise, she had seen the Broadway show mentioned in the script and even sang a song from it. It was an incredible moment of alignment that solidified her involvement.
Who else is on your casting wish list?
There are many actors I admire, but Catherine O’Hara is someone I would love to work with. Finding the right project for her is a goal of mine.
This story first appeared in an August stand-alone issue of The Hollywood Reporter magazine. To receive the magazine, click here to subscribe.