Trevor from Love Is Blind addresses girlfriend claim off-screen
Did Shayne and Natalie get engaged or not? In season two, Shayne proposed to Natalie Lee but Shaina also expressed her feelings for him. Despite not getting married in the finale, Shayne and Natalie attempted to reconcile their relationship off-camera. However, during Love Is Blind After the Altar, Natalie disclosed finding “flirtatious messages” between her boyfriend and Shaina discussing what might have happened if they had ended up together. This discovery ultimately led to the end of their romance, as Natalie stated, “That’s why we’re not together anymore.”
On After the Altar, Shaina claimed it was “slander” and insisted to Shayne that they had always maintained appropriate boundaries and never spent time alone together, despite evidence suggesting otherwise.
In an interview with Entertainment Tonight, Natalie implied that there were additional conversations between Shayne and Shaina that were not shown on the show. She mentioned having text messages and emails detailing Shayne attempting to retract Instagram messages and delete conversations, including the DMs with Shaina. These omitted details, according to Natalie, would have added crucial context to the situation.