Jimmy from Love Is Blind addresses claims about his off-screen girlfriend
After Shayne proposed to Natalie Lee in season two, Shaina expressed her feelings for him. Following Shayne and Natalie’s decision not to get married in the finale, they attempted to salvage their relationship off-camera. However, during Love Is Blind After the Altar, Natalie disclosed that she found “flirtatious messages” between her boyfriend and Shaina discussing “what would have happened if they ended up together.” This discovery ultimately led to the end of their romance, as Natalie explained, “That’s why we’re not together anymore.”
On After the Altar, Shaina denied the allegations, stating to Shayne, “We’ve always been appropriate. We’ve never hung out alone.” (However, at the time, they were indeed hanging out alone.)
In an interview with Entertainment Tonight, Natalie implied that there were “a lot more” of Shayne and Shaina’s conversations that were not shown. She said, “I understand, in terms of how much you can really show in these three 45-minute-long episodes, but what I do have is, again, text messages and emails with Shayne, talking about him unsending Instagram messages, deleting messages, and those DMs with Shaina, so that’s something that I talked about that didn’t make the cut, that I think kind of would have helped with the story.”