Jimmy from Love Is Blind defends his comment about Chelsea’s sex life
After Shayne proposed to Natalie Lee in season two, questions arose about his relationship with Shaina. Despite not marrying Natalie in the finale, Shayne and Natalie tried to make things work off-camera. However, during Love Is Blind After the Altar, Natalie disclosed that she found “flirtatious messages” between Shayne and Shaina discussing what could have been if they were together. This revelation led to the end of Shayne and Natalie’s relationship.
Shaina denied the accusations on After the Altar, claiming it was “slander” and insisting that they had always maintained appropriate boundaries. Yet, it was later revealed that they had spent time alone together.
In an interview with Entertainment Tonight, Natalie hinted that more of Shayne and Shaina’s exchanges were not shown on the show. She mentioned texts and emails with Shayne discussing him deleting messages, including DMs with Shaina, which were not included in the final cut, potentially altering the narrative.