Jess from Love Is Blind Criticizes Jimmy for Hurtful Comments
Did they or didn’t they? Shayne proposed to Natalie Lee in season two, but Shaina also expressed her feelings for him. When Shayne and Natalie didn’t tie the knot in the finale, they attempted to salvage their relationship off-camera. However, Natalie later revealed on Love Is Blind After the Altar that she found “flirtatious messages” between her boyfriend and Shaina discussing “what could have been if they ended up together.” This discovery ultimately led to the end of their romance, as Natalie explained, “That’s why we’re not together anymore.”
During After the Altar, Shaina claimed it was “slander,” insisting to Shayne, “We’ve always kept things appropriate. We’ve never spent time alone” (even though they were indeed spending time alone at the time).
In an interview with Entertainment Tonight, Natalie hinted that there was “a lot more” of Shayne and Shaina’s interactions that were not shown on the show. She said, “I understand the limitations of a three-episode series, but I have text messages and emails from Shayne discussing deleting Instagram messages and the DMs with Shaina. These details would have added more depth to the story.”